I absolutely love these gel liners by Physicians Formula. I originally purchased them after seeing several of my friends rave about them (though it took me months to find them!). I purchased the Blue Eyes set, which has a Blue Liner, Brown Liner and Black with Blue Glitter liner.
Like the Maybelline Gel liners, what you see in the container is the color you get. You only need to swipe the color once to get a really solid line. The liner will last all day and night, as it claims.
These are my favorite drugstore liners for several reasons. You get 3 liners for $10.99. They’re easy to clean off of my brushes as well as my eyes. Dr. Bronners will easily cleanse them off of my eyeliner brushes. My Nyx eye and lip makeup remover will easily remove them from my eyes. The colors are supposed to flatter blue eyes. My eyes are blue-green, and I REALLY love how the black liner with the blue glitter looks. I’ve been wearing it almost exclusively since I got it. It’s a nice true black and the blue sparks add a bit of sparkle without being over the top. The blue liner is really wearable and is dark without being a harsh or stark line. The brown is ok, but I don’t really wear brown much.
Overall, I LOVE these liners. I will purchase them again. I do wish I could purchase just the black shade on its own, or with other similar shades with different colored sparkles in it.