Recently I had a request for swatching Sugarpill Stella with Fyrinnae Fyre & Ice to see how close they were. I also swatched Fyrinnae Immortality. I feel like Immortality is much closer to Stella than Fyre & Ice.
Stella – the blackest of jet blacks, bursting with rainbow diamond sparkle.
Fyre & Ice – a myriad of colorful sparkles on black, purple, pink and blue dominating.
Immortality – a rainbow of sparkle in black.
To me, you can see the purple and pink easily in Fyre & Ice.
Stella has the darkest black base, but similar rainbow sparkle to Immortality.
Immortality has a softer black base, but similar rainbow sparkle to Stella.
I think all three are gorgeous.
Facebook
Twitter
GooglePlus
RSS
Klout
Youtube
Email
Pinterest
MakeupBee
BlogLovin'
Makeup Geek
Hello Cotton
I thought they might be very similar, thanks for comparing them, I’ll save my money for other gorgeous Sugarpill products that I don’t already have similar shades to.
Minou recently shared..I WON!
You’re quite welcome Minou!
Gorgeous colors even though there is little difference from what I can see!
The differences are subtle
Thank you so much again for the comparison!
I think I’ll skip out on Stella, since I already have Immortality.
You’re quite welcome!
They are all very similar – how is the application of them all, is it pretty much the same?
Kate recently shared..Geek Post- Not For the Faint of Heart or Weak of Stomach
Fyre & Ice looks like black base with pink and purple shimmer to me.
Stella is a very deep opaque black base with rainbow sparkles.
Immortality is a lighter black base with rainbow sparkles.
They all apply nicely, as both Fyrinnae and Sugarpill are well made.
I love Fyre & Ice !!
It is certainly pretty!
Ooooh I think I’d opt for Immortality over Stella :3
SilhouetteScreams recently shared..Deserter
I think they’re good for different situations. Immortality is good for darkening a crease, whereas Stella is fantastic for a liner
I wonder how they compare to Sassy’s Gasoline Rainbow? I have almost bought Immortality several times, but worried I’d be buying a dupe – and I’d rather spend money on completely new-to-me colors
I have Gasoline Rainbow, and I seem to recall that Immortality is more sparkly. They’re very close though, so if you already have Gasoline Rainbow, unless you’re a black rainbow eye shadow fiend you probably don’t need it.