Recently I had several people tell me I should check out Beautylush Co on Etsy. I’ve seen the company around several times, so I decided to purchase some shades to try out.


I purchased Peach Sorbet, Rose Gold, Summer Sky and Nova. I received samples of the rest of the colors. All colors swatched on Meow Light Primer.

Peach Sorbet
Beautiful peach/ pink color with gold highlight
My Take
Peach with golden sheen. I love this sort of shade. This is a reasonably good dupe for Urban Decay Freelove, if you’re a fan of that shade like I am.

Rose Gold
Warm rose/ gold colored eye shadow
My Take
Bronzed gold metallic shade with a hint of rose-gold. This is really pretty and would be awesome on the lid and crease for a multi-dimensional golden-bronze-metallic eye.

Gold Tips
Mustard/ gold colored eye shadow
My Take
Mustard yellow gold metallic. Not my favorite sort of shade.

Saddle
Dark Brown
My Take
Deep rich brown with gold glimmers, really nice for a brown.

Sausalito
Light Blue
My Take
Soft light turquoise blue.

Posh
A bright magenta colored eye shadow with blue highlights
My Take
Midtone watermelon pink with slight pinkish-violet sheen. I don’t see blue highlights but from certain angles I do see pink-violet.

Tea Rose
Shimmer, light pink, with lavender undertones
My Take
Soft lavender pink, ultra feminine.

Rodeo
A dark green eye shadow with gold highlights
My Take
Midtone green with slight gold shimmer.

Summer Sky
Dark teal/ turquoise with gold undertones
My Take
Rich emerald green with blue undertones. I don’t see any gold or teal. Very disappointing to me, because I wanted this to be a dark blue teal. This color actually reminds me of Urban Decay Clinic.

Firefly
A shimmer blue/ green eye shadow
My Take
Green with slight golden overtone and blue-green undertone. This is the closest to teal by my standards.

Nova
Blue/ purple colored eye shadow with blue highlights
My Take
My first one arrived broken and it matched the shadow description. The second one I received just looked like a navy blue eyeshadow. I was a little concerned about the consistency of shadows between batches because of the color discrepancy between the Nova shadows. However, my first Rose Gold also arrived broken, and both of the Rose Gold shades matched.

On that note, the customer service was exemplary. When I contacted the seller and let her know that 2 of my shades had broken, she immediately sent out replacements.

Barely
Satin/ golden bronze
My Take
It says it’s a highlighter but it reads as a bronzer on my skin. It’s a really pretty golden bronze.

Fuchsia
Matte bright pink
My Take
Perfect matte fuchsia color. Utterly flattering and natural on me.

Tootsie
Matte watermelon pink blush
My Take
Very pretty warm bright watermelon pink blush.

Wearing Peach Sorbet on my lid, Rose Gold for the crease, Summer Sky for the lower lash line and outer crease, Firefly for the lower lid.

Eye shadow Ingredients:
Mica, titanium dioxide, magnesium myristrate
May contain: iron oxide, tin oxide, kaolin, carmine, ferric ferrocyanide, chromium oxide green, ultramarines, manganese violet, yellow 5, blue 1, red 40, boron nitride, aluminum powder, talc, silicone dioxide, Lauroyl Lysine, hydrogenated polyisobutene, palmitic acid, carnauba wax, myristic acid, magnesium hydroxide, boron oxide, zinc stearate, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, isopropyl myristrate, bis- vinyl dimethicone, dimethicone, methicone

Blush Ingredients:
Mica, titanium dioxide, magnesium myristrate
May contain: Iron oxide, tin oxide, aluminum powder, carmine, boron nitride, boron oxide, talc, silicone dioxide, ferric ferrocyanide, chromium oxide green, ultramarines, manganese violet, yellow 5, blue 1, red 40, red 7 Ca lake, red 30, yellow 7, yellow 10, orange 5, red 28, violet 2, red 22, hydrogenated polyisobutene, palmitic acid, carnauba wax, myristic acid, magnesium hydroxide, polymethylhydrogen siloxane, polyester 3, methicone

Price:
$5.50 for loose
$6.50 for pressed
$7.50 for blush
Shipping was $5.25 for my order

The eyeshadows wore for 8 hours on my TFSI with no creasing, looking as fresh as when I applied it. I think the eyeshadow formula itself is great.

The blushes were nice and I didn’t need much to give my cheeks a natural flush. They wore fairly well, though I think there was fading after about 6 hours.

The color description discrepancies with the teal Summer Sky was disappointing. The color variance between Nova was odd.

Overall, I’m happy with my shadows and I feel the color descriptions are mostly accurate. The formula is nice and long wearing.

Would I purchase from Beautylush co again?
Yes, as long as I could find skin swatches of the shade I wanted to purchase. The product formulas I tried are nice, the price is reasonable and the customer service is excellent.

Rating: