hit counter

Makeup Wars – Favorite Fall Nail Colors

It’s time for another round of Makeup Wars. This time we’re showing off our Favorite Fall Nail Colors!

Row 1: Orly Prisma Gloss Gold – Pretty Serious Morning Java – NARS Desperado – Cult Nails Iconic – Cult Nails Let Me Fly – Cult Nails Living Water
Row 2: butter London Wallis – butter London the Full Monty – Nubar Gold Leaf – Nubar Peacock Feathers? – Rimmel 615 Night Before – Sally Hansen Burgundy Orchid

Now, I’m never good at choosing just one thing. Ever. So these are my favorite colors for Fall. A few colors are transitional and can be worn all year round, such as Cult Nails Let Me Fly and butter London the Full Monty. Also, I layer Orly Prisma Gloss Gold (or Silver) over nearly everything I own.

Some of these polishes I’ve had for years, others are new. Sally Hansen Burgundy Orchid (I used to have this entire line and threw out a bunch of them because I didn’t know that you could revive old, goopy nail polish!) is a long-time favorite of mine and I really wish some indie company would create a cruelty-free duochrome like this shade. Burgundy Orchid shifts between a beautiful burgundy red and purple. It’s not big 3 free, it’s really stinky, but it’s super pretty.

Cult Nails Iconic is a gorgeous berry red crème combines with stunning gold shimmer and red flakes. I put a layer of Orly Prisma Gloss Gold on top for a bit of extra gold shimmer, because I think that makes it more suitable for Fall.

Nubar Gold Leaf was my first Nubar Polish, and very nearly my last! I had HORRIBLE customer service from them and have been hesitant to purchase their products ever since, despite loving this polish so much. It’s a wonderful amber with burgundy around the edges and gold highlights. It’s breathtaking and I love it for Fall. It’s too bad, really, because they have gorgeous polishes.

Nubar Peacock Feather. I’m not actually sure that this polish is named Peacock Feather. The name of the polish fell off the bottle (poor design in my opinion). But it’s a gorgeous color. It’s a teal blue base with purple and blue shimmer.

Rimmel 615 Night Before. This is a gorgeous inky indigo and purple duochrome. It’s nearly opaque in one coat.

Pretty Serious Morning Java with a coat of Orly Prisma Gloss Gold. This is another color that screams Fall to me. It’s a rich coffee brown with golden bronze flecks.

butter London Wallis. It’s a tarnished, metallic olive gold nail lacquer. I love that it’s such a complex color.

butter London the Full Monty. It’s a pale neutral molten gold. I love it. It’s definitely classy.

NARS Desperado. I went hunting down this rich, complex golden shade. It’s got amber, pale gold, and rich caramel tones. This is my Preciousssssssssssssssssssss. Seriously though, it should be part of the core collection, it’s so gorgeous!

Cult Nails Let Me Fly. I put a coat of Orly Prisma Gloss Gold on top. I LOVE this teal. It’s so awesome. It’s perfect all year round. I especially love it for Summer or Fall.

Cult Nails Living Water. I need to figure out how to apply it sheerly to all of my nails like above on the nail wheel. It’s beautiful! I love deep dark teals. They seem perfect for Fall or Winter.


Ahh, duochromes, teals, golds and burgundies! Perfect shades for Fall. These are my favorites for the best Fall nail polish shades.

Check out the rest of the Makeup Wars polish choices!

To the best of my knowledge:
Cult Nails is cruelty-free.
butter London is cruelty-free.
Pretty Serious is cruelty-free.
NARS is cruelty-free.
Nubar is cruelty-free.
Orly is cruelty-free.
Rimmel is not cruelty-free.
Sally Hansen is not cruelty-free.

Some products purchased by me. Some products sent for consideration. All opinions are my own.

  • From our partners
    • http://www.blushingnoir.com Brooke @ BlushingNoir

      I totally just drooled on my desk

      • Phyrra

        LOL! Which did you like best?

    • http://www.beautyandfashiontech.com Carleen

      Very nice selection! I love the coppery type shades. That is something I always like in photos, but rarely buy in the store. I should see how one looks on me sometime!

      • Phyrra

        Thank you! I only like the coppery ones if they flash another shade, like burgundy or gold :)

    • http://perilouslypale.com Perilously Pale

      Umm that’s a lot of favourites! LOL Cheater! I can’t wait to pull out Wallis again this fall. I need to check out the rest of those.

      • Phyrra

        I can’t ever pick just one. Seriously. My hair isn’t even just one color. I’ve got it narrowed down to 3.

    • http://www.15minutebeauty.com Christine

      Ooooh, I might need to try out a few more golds this fall. So pretty!

      • Phyrra

        Yes! Go for golds :)

    • http://www.beautyinfozone.com MarciaF (beauty info zone)

      You are evil!! Look how many polishes I’ll now covet. You already “made” me buy some Cult and now I want your others. I think I have Peacock Feathers so I’ll have to make sure.

    • http://plannedresilience.net/ Eleanor

      Oooooh, GOT to get me some of that Desperado (hope they still sell it). I was looking for a polish just like that the other day, but clearly I was in the wrong store. Better get to Nordstrom this weekend. I was attracted to the Butter London Wallis too, but I wasn’t sure about it. Now I know I definitely NEED that one too.

      Thanks Phyrra :D

    • http://orangelipstickblog.blogspot.com/ OrangeLipstickBlog

      Peacock Feather is beautiful! My favorite fall polish is Orly Plum Noir.

    • http://www.pammyblogsbeauty.com Pammy

      Nice assortment! I am partial to the blue/purple shades. :)

    • http://pearlsquirrel.blogspot.com Pearl Squirrel

      I love every single one. They go together great too, you should try and wear them all together in one mani :)

    • http://www.primebeautyblog.net Cindy (Prime Beauty)

      All nice but Burgundy Orchid is fabulous!

    • http://www.midnightmanicures.com/ Midnight Manicures

      I love your taste in nail polish. I need (must have) NARS Desperado!

    • http://beautifulmakeupsearch.com Teri

      Nice picks! I guess you had a hard time picking out just a few ;)

    • Pingback: Beach Romance, Mermaids Underwater and More! | Phyrra | Beauty for the Bold

    • Pingback: we heart this - The Lipstick League – week of 9.3.12

    • Pingback: The Lipstick League – Week of 3.9.12 | A Makeup & Beauty Blog - Lipglossiping

    • Pingback: The Lipstick League: Weekly Links, Volume 58 - Clumps of Mascara

    • http://www.geniabeme.com Eugenia

      Wow! So many pretty colors! I am really liking Full Monty!

    • misfitgirlie

      Of these, I have Cult Nails Iconic, Cult Nails Living Water, Butter London Wallis, and NARS Desperado. I like the Rimmel and I like the Morning Java with the gold on top!

    • Pingback: Haircare, Sephora’s Colors of the Season and More from the Lipstick League | Phyrra | Beauty for the Bold

    • http://addictedtoopi-yum.blogspot.com/ lovenailpolish

      Excellent fall selection. These are gorgeous beyond belief, and when they are all together on the nail wheel it is almost too much to bear!

      I am still wearing summer polishes. I don’t really enjoy fall/winter tones with my skin tone. I have dark olive skin and many tend to just seem blah. I like fall colors though.

      I have the nail prism, I rarely wear them, they are my precioussssss….

      I really like the Orly and the Pretty Serious. I need to check into those.


    • Pingback: Makeup Wars Beauty Resolutions | Phyrra | Beauty for the Bold